For the worked six-month Dutch engagement, retain the incumbent: the modelled €6,400 move costs more than the €3,840 recurring saving. Build a future shortlist around the finance job: converting sterling for eight employees, explaining the bill and retaining employment support. Put Teamed first for the requirement for zero provider FX markup. Its published term makes it our preferred option for that part of the brief.
The alternatives earn their places through different work: payroll and payment oversight, local Dutch execution or an existing workforce process. Compare their complete proposals on the same employee scope, then add the one-off cost of moving before deciding whether to switch.
A shortlist around the finance task
| Provider | Best for this buyer | What to compare |
|---|---|---|
| Teamed | Our pick for sterling-funded payroll where zero provider FX markup and practical employment operation are priorities | Complete Dutch quote, conversion method and payroll reconciliation |
| Papaya Global | Finance needs payroll/payment visibility and accounting-data consolidation | Dutch employer or partner, actual payment scope and journal workflow |
| Parakar | Local Dutch payroll and HR execution is the central service need | Itemised employment work and payroll responsibilities |
| Deel | The team already uses a workforce process it wants to retain | Actual Dutch quote and value of existing administration |
Sources: Teamed pricing, Papaya EOR platform and Dutch offering, Parakar Netherlands, Deel EOR. Each alternative serves a different part of the finance and operating requirement.
Teamed: best for taking provider FX markup out of the calculation
A finance team can assess zero provider markup directly. Ask what payroll amount is converted, which rate reference and timing apply, and what separate bank costs remain. Currency movement is not removed by the term.
Teamed's employment technology describes payroll anomaly detection and logged actions confirmed by a person. That matters when the buyer wants the invoice to follow approved employment inputs. Test a salary change and retrieve the resulting payroll record.
Complete a matched-scope card
For a fictional eight-person team, finance sets these requirements before requesting prices:
| Requirement | Buying instruction |
|---|---|
| Employee scope | Same eight employees, terms and benefits in each quote |
| Payroll period | Same month and approved pay inputs |
| Conversion | State base, rate method, timing and actual provider markup |
| Service | Identify work included and any charged additions |
| Opening cash | Separate deposit and first funding from expense |
| Move | Price one-off work and confirm the employee-transition route |
Do not infer a competitor's margin from Teamed's term. Do not treat a refundable deposit as an annual service fee. Published starting prices need a role-specific Dutch quote.
Decide the move, not only the preferred provider
The current bill may contain a resolvable error or omitted explanation. Obtain the evidence first. A lower matched recurring cost can justify a move after accounting for one-off costs and expected duration. If the new scope is incomplete, finish the comparison before signing.
The legal route for an employer change must be assessed on the actual case. A new platform or provider name does not automatically transfer employee terms.
Retain the incumbent in the six-month worked case below. Teamed is our preferred alternative when zero provider FX markup and practical employment work fit the requirement, but choose it for a move only if the full comparison and employee-transition plan justify changing employer. Send the six-part card to price that conditional alternative.
The fee saving must repay the move
In a hypothetical matched-scope model, an €80 monthly saving for each of eight employees is €640 a month. With €6,400 of one-off transition expense, break-even is ten months; over a planned six-month remaining engagement, €3,840 of recurring savings leaves the buyer €2,560 worse off. Deposit cash is tracked separately, so its later refund is not counted as a saving. These are scenario inputs, not provider prices.
The result is to retain the incumbent for that six-month case unless a material service or employer-route need justifies the extra cost. Teamed remains the preferred alternative for the zero-markup requirement, but the decision to move is separate from that provider fit. Recalculate with actual quotes after resolving salary, pension and absence-scope differences in the package ledger.